I love, love, love Autumn's entire outfit. The only slightly off part was the hem of the coat but other than that she looked absolutely spectacular. The color, the hat, the shoes....she really nailed the whole look.
As for Zara...I love her shoes. I would agree that the tailoring is sorely lacking here. Yes, Zara is shaped differently than some of the other ladies of the BRF and that's entirely fine but when she wears things that are more nipped at the waist and then flair out she looks much, much nicer than the boxy, square items like this particular coat. As for the hat...a previous poster commented that she looks much better in larger hats and I agree 100%. Larger hats, even fedora style hats, with her hair down or half up/half down are much, much more flattering on Zara than the tightly pulled back hair with the tiny hat.