Okay, to start off my comments/response to several who replied to my initial comments about Kate's speech, I'll offer some
.
The youngsters whom I have had the pleasure of seeing deliver better speeches, even first ones, than Kate, most assuredly did not have television news cameras recording them so that the speeches could be streamed live around the world. That isn't to say that the pressure they were feeling, at 13, 14 or 15 years old, is any less than what Kate was feeling yesterday. There is a fair degree of pressure to stand up and give a speech with a hundred people, some of whom can be as critical and will gladly nitpick every little thing the same way Kate's worst critics do (think about the worst old biddies, and plenty of younger ones in training). Ultimately though, it's apples to oranges, comparing the pressures.
Having said that, my personal experience in watching some of these kids deliver speeches, especially their first ones, is that I thought Kate took too long when she was looking down to read her speech for someone who is reported to have written it herself and practiced so much. I just felt like the delivery wasn't very organic and it made me feel like Kate was reading another person's words. I wasn't expecting her to have a teleprompter so that she could be constantly looking around and engaging the audience but even her quip about wishing William could be there was stiffly delivered. It was, overall, a really oddly presented speech, to me.
For what it's worth, I posted a link to the speech on my FB and several friends all agreed that it was not great.
I'm a Kate fan in general and I think she's a fabulous addition to the BRF and while I'm sure she'll improve over time, I doubt her speeches are ever going to be her forte. All this fawning all over her and excusing her rather uncomfortable and clearly nervous effort is as off-putting as the people who tear her down every chance they get.