King Juan Carlos Announces Abdication: June 2, 2014


If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
So happy for them! They'll do an amazing job :) They're everything that Spain needs right now
 
so surprising i really hope that has nothing to do with the King health.
Prince Felipe i think is well prepared to take over and its about time;the new generation of royal is taking the lead in Europe and it good to see.
i hope that the first visit to King Felipe and Queen Letizia abroad will be to Morocco:p
good luck to them.
 
He did it because it was time for him to. His popularity is low , the scandals are many and there wasn't anything he could do to bring it back. It was time to make a change. Something had to be done.

Sent from my SCH-I545 using The Royals Community mobile app
 
Like everyone else, this news produced a gasp from me when I heard it during the Supper Hour Newscast. While his health has not been good of late, I just have a funny feeling it's not the only reason why Juan Carlos is taking this step now. Don't know why, but I just do.

God Save King Felipe and Queen Letitzia!!
 
My Thoughts on Abdication

Like most who have commented here, I was shocked this morning when I heard the news.


I am a bit torn about abdication.

On the one hand, I hate to see this old tradition of staying till the bitter end die. (pardon the pun) However, we must remember that when it came into being, average life expectancy was about 55. Now people can live to a very great age.
I fully expect that Queen Elizabeth II can possibly go on for another 10 years. Not quite so sure about Queen Margaurite II because she is a heavy smoker.

Also, abdication can be seen as a very humane gesture to your child. They are not waiting for you to die to achieve their purpose in life. I recall Princess Victoria once saying with incredulity that a reporter had asked her if she looked forward to the day she came to the throne. She said "Don't they know they are talking about my father dying?"

If one is not abdicating in a cloud of controversy (and I am not implying this is the case...I don't know enough about the circumstances), it can allow the succession of the next in line to be a fully joyous occasion, not a time of mourning and some feelings of guilt. JMO.

Ana
 
Duke of Marmalade said:
I wonder what went on behind the scenes. The old man will surely have protected himself. This will be hard on everybody, we'll see how active for example Sofia will stay. Juan Carlos will probably become some kind of Elder Statesman, still using his connections. There will be a lot of pressure on the Asturias family now, Leonor becoming Princess of Asturias at the age of 9.
Click to expand...


Felipe and Letizia are ready for this and I have no doubt that they will be be popular monarchs. But Leo has been one of the most sheltered Royal children ever...I hope the transition will be smooth for that little girl. She is now the Princess of Asturias and Heiress Presumptive!
 
Ana Von Cleves said:
Like most who have commented here, I was shocked this morning when I heard the news.


I am a bit torn about abdication.

On the one hand, I hate to see this old tradition of staying till the bitter end die. (pardon the pun) However, we must remember that when it came into being, average life expectancy was about 55. Now people can live to a very great age.
I fully expect that Queen Elizabeth II can possibly go on for another 10 years. Not quite so sure about Queen Margaurite II because she is a heavy smoker.

Also, abdication can be seen as a very humane gesture to your child. They are not waiting for you to die to achieve their purpose in life. I recall Princess Victoria once saying with incredulity that a reporter had asked her if she looked forward to the day she came to the throne. She said "Don't they know they are talking about my father dying?"

If one is not abdicating in a cloud of controversy (and I am not implying this is the case...I don't know enough about the circumstances), it can allow the succession of the next in line to be a fully joyous occasion, not a time of mourning and some feelings of guilt. JMO.

Ana
Click to expand...

It can also be a time of great joy. I saw a number of videos of Princess Beatrix and King Willem-Alexander together signing official documents, appearing on the balcony together. They both seemed very happy. I would imagine it gave her great joy to see her son take the throne and know that she would be there to help him in his new role. Rather like we like to see our children graduate school and get married. To share such an important moment in her child's life.
 
Excalibur said:
Not exactly. Upon the death of her husband, George VI, Queen Elizabeth was officially entitled to the style The Dowager Queen, but she was also entitled to the style of The Queen Mother, as she was the mother of the sovereign. Needing a distinct style (so as to differentiate between herself and the new sovereign, Queen Elizabeth II) and not wanting to be known as Dowager Queen Elizabeth, she chose to be known as Queen Elizabeth The Queen Mother. It was not honorary, it was official; and by all accounts she revelled in being known as The Queen Mum.
Click to expand...
You might be correct but I was copying directly from a bio on the Queen Mum. Author even stated a time when QM told an editor of Times she didn't like be called the Queen Mother. She preferred "Mother of the Queen".
 
Ana Von Cleves said:
Like most who have commented here, I was shocked this morning when I heard the news.


I am a bit torn about abdication.

On the one hand, I hate to see this old tradition of staying till the bitter end die. (pardon the pun) However, we must remember that when it came into being, average life expectancy was about 55. Now people can live to a very great age.
I fully expect that Queen Elizabeth II can possibly go on for another 10 years. Not quite so sure about Queen Margaurite II because she is a heavy smoker.

Also, abdication can be seen as a very humane gesture to your child. They are not waiting for you to die to achieve their purpose in life. I recall Princess Victoria once saying with incredulity that a reporter had asked her if she looked forward to the day she came to the throne. She said "Don't they know they are talking about my father dying?"

If one is not abdicating in a cloud of controversy (and I am not implying this is the case...I don't know enough about the circumstances), it can allow the succession of the next in line to be a fully joyous occasion, not a time of mourning and some feelings of guilt. JMO.

Ana
Click to expand...


To me I think some of the "staying until the bitter end" aspect of it is because of the oaths they take and the religious aspect. It's not so much because once upon a time monarchs were expected to die younger (there are a good number of monarchs who lived fairly long, and many of those who didn't were either warriors or lived unhealthy lifestyles), but because they had been chosen by God and anointed as King. This issue comes up fairly frequently in the history of usurpation and abdication in English history, as even the people who had pushed out the previous king often weren't okay with killing an anointed king.

Look at Elizabeth II. She was raised to believe that it was her God given duty to be royal and be the monarch. She was taught that the worst thing she could do was abdicate - and to do so was to accept living in exile, without her home or family. Even she before she was monarch she publicly vowed to dedicate her life to serving her people, and in her coronation she did so before both her people and her God. This isn't something that she's likely to take lightly or really reconsider, given how she was raised, her dedication, and her strong religious beliefs.

In the Netherlands it's different. The monarchy is younger and they don't have the history of monarchs reigning until death. 4 out of 6 monarchs (excluding WA) have abdicated, and of the 2 that didn't it's easy to see how circumstances prevented them from doing so (one being rather young when he died, the other being older but having a 10 year old heir). The Dutch monarchs don't vow to serve for life before God, so when they chose to abdicate it has very different implications.

I feel for JC, as well as Albert and Benedict before him, since they've all essentially been forced into doing something that goes against the nature of their titles, positions, and oaths. Each man may have very well come to the decision to abdicate on their own, but I don't think for a moment that it was something any did lightly or with any degree of ease or happiness - it may have been their choice, but I fully believed the circumstances around them forced them into the decision. To me, this growing trend of monarchs being forced to abdicate in no small part because of scandal is not a good sign for the future of monarchies. It might be a fix for now, and a necessary one at that, but it can be a crack in the foundation of the concept, especially for realms where there is no tradition of abdication and/or there is a tradition of mass demonstrations or republicanism.
 
[To me, this growing trend of monarchs being forced to abdicate in no small part because of scandal is not a good sign for the future of monarchies. It might be a fix for now, and a necessary one at that, but it can be a crack in the foundation of the concept, especially for realms where there is no tradition of abdication and/or there is a tradition of mass demonstrations or republicanism. ]// quote Ish

So very true. Your entire post is spot on but this last paragraph really struck a chord. Among some, the push for abdication is because the Royal watchers-media included- want to see a younger and more photogenic couple on the Throne. You can see this sentiment especially among those who want to see the Prince of Wales passed over in favor of William.

I am not sure this abdication trend is a good thing at all for the future of any of the remaining monarchies. Hurray for QEII for bucking the trend!
 
carlota said:
interesting declarations of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna on the abdication:


The Russian Imperial House of Romanov has expressed regret over the abdication of the throne by King Juan Carlos of Spain in favor of his son, Felipe of Asturias. The head of the House of Romanov, Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna, lives in Spain.
Click to expand...

A rather shameful declaration by Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna, again showing she has no any understanding of democratic processes and modern kingship. It is shameful because from no one else she received so much hospitality than from Don Juan Carlos, arranging for her to live in Madrid.

What a brutal and disqualifying declaration from Maria Vladimirovna.

:sad:
 
What do you think how sucessful are the republican movements in Spain now?
 
principessa said:
What do you think how sucessful are the republican movements in Spain now?
Click to expand...

It is not really a republican movement, it is the reqular mix of separatists, anti-globalists, occupy movement, anarchists, squatters, anti-everythingers, disillusioned citizens and the usual sweepstake actions by social media.

There are always protests in Spanish cities. This time they grabbed the opportunity and worldwide media attention to get rid of the monarchy. As if by magic a president would solve Spain's deep problems...
 
Moonmaiden23 said:
[To me, this growing trend of monarchs being forced to abdicate in no small part because of scandal is not a good sign for the future of monarchies. It might be a fix for now, and a necessary one at that, but it can be a crack in the foundation of the concept, especially for realms where there is no tradition of abdication and/or there is a tradition of mass demonstrations or republicanism. ]// quote Ish

So very true. Your entire post is spot on but this last paragraph really struck a chord. Among some, the push for abdication is because the Royal watchers-media included- want to see a younger and more photogenic couple on the Throne. You can see this sentiment especially among those who want to see the Prince of Wales passed over in favor of William.

I am not sure this abdication trend is a good thing at all for the future of any of the remaining monarchies. Hurray for QEII for bucking the trend!
Click to expand...



Couldn´t agree more! The trend "We´re cross with the king we have. Let´s have the next one!" is a very dangerous one for the institution of monarchy! The concept to change when someone falls out of favour is a profoundly republican, not a monarchial one.
Let´s face it: If both Kings Albert II and Juan Carlos still had the full support of the public and media, they´d still be in office!
I pity CP Félipe: His accession won´t be a smooth one by any means...
And now happens what I thought before would happen: The spanish republicans embrace the opportunity and try to abolish the monarchy completely now...!
If Félipe and Letizia will really manage to succeed they are sadly very likely to become the last monarchs of Spain....
 
wartenberg7 said:
And now happens what I thought before would happen: The spanish republicans embrace the opportunity and try to abolish the monarchy completely now...!
Click to expand...
And you think that would not have happened in the case of JC's death?
 
I wasn't surprised he abdicated.

It didn't get much attention in my area, just a crawl during the morning news.
 
wartenberg7 said:
If Félipe and Letizia will really manage to succeed they are sadly very likely to become the last monarchs of Spain....
Click to expand...

And why not? As much as Juan Carlos did the transition from dictatorship to democracy, Felipe's role could be guiding the country from unitary parliamentary constitutional monrachy to a republic, if this turns out what people want in the next decade or so. Felipe is not stupid, at the end of the day monarchy has become outdated and Spain has never been a classic monarchistic country unlike eg the nordic countries, that seem to enjoy the pomp and glamour part.
 
wartenberg7 said:
Let´s face it: If both Kings Albert II and Juan Carlos still had the full support of the public and media, they´d still be in office!
Click to expand...

Heu...

Queen Wilhelmina had no full support of the public in 1948?
Grand Duchess Charlotte had no full support of the public in 1962?
Queen Juliana had no full support of the public in 1980?
Grand Duke Jean had no full support of the public in 2000?
Queen Beatrix had no full support of the public in 2013?

I am also not aware of any urge for King Albert II and King Juan Carlos to step down, apart from their ailing physical health with the advancing of the years. They abdicated completely voluntarily.

Note that the "abdicating monarchies" Netherlands and Luxemburg do -interesting enough- have the most firmly-rooted Royal Houses, looking at their position in society and popular approval. No one can say that the abdications have undermined these institutions.

In her memoires "Lonely, but not alone" Queen Wilhelmina wrote that she was inspired by the adbications of Charles V as Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, King of Spain, King of Naples and the Two Sicilies, Archduke of Austria and Lord of the Netherlands in 1555 and 1556. In this sense, abdications are really nothing new, not for Spain and not for the Low Countries.

Picture: the abdication of Charles V. His son and Heir Felipe II bows to his father and brings homage, the Emperor leans on the shoulders of William of Nassau, Prince of Orange, his loyal Stadtholder in the Netherlands. (Later Felipe and William would become arch-enemies). Picture from Wikipedia: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/Abdication_de_charles_quint_Louis_Gallait.jpg
 
Last edited:
Today the King and Prince attend a military ceremony in El Escorial. The reference to Carlos V and Felipe II is now even more inevitable.

There are 200 media following the event.
 
lula said:
The reference to Carlos V and Felipe II is now even more inevitable.
Click to expand...
Oh, indeed.

But talk about a succesful process of abdication- sucession ;)

I´m so looking foward the event today. It´s everything very symbolic: El Escorial, both King and future King alone, military event+parade...

I´ll admit that with all this issue I´m getting quite sentimental :lol:
 
And both Holy Roman Emperor & King Charles V/I and King Philip II are buried within the El Escorial Monastery!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Blog Real
  • Sticky
"Reconciliation" (2024): Memoirs of King Juan Carlos I
Replies
17
Views
3K
An Ard Ri
An Ard Ri
An Ard Ri
  • Sticky
Birthday and anniversary wishes for the Royal Family of the Spain 2024
2
Replies
42
Views
3K
An Ard Ri
An Ard Ri
Blog Real
King Carlo Emanuele IV (1751-1819) and Queen Marie Clotilde of France
Replies
1
Views
575
CyrilVladisla
CyrilVladisla
lula
10th anniversary of the Proclamation of HM King Felipe VI. June 19, 2024.
2
Replies
59
Views
7K
lula
lula
An Ard Ri
  • Sticky
King Felipe VI and Queen Letizia's Current Events 5: June 2024 -
Replies
18
Views
4K
Toledo
Toledo

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom