Does IHA allow her to do all her private outings because of the advice by her medical team? If so, why do many people unaware of this and accuse her of being a 'lazy princess that refuses to do her duties'?
Hello, Sanchia, welcome!
The problem is that there is hardly any reliable official information about what the imperials can or cannot do. As far as I can see it seems to be even doubtful, for example, if they can make a telephone call by themselves or have a private number where friends or family can directly reach them. On the other hand, even if they do not have such a number it seems to be doubtful that their secretary (or whoever is taking up the phone) would decide on their own who they think fit to connect to them and who not, so it should not be supposed to make such a difference if they have a private telephone number. Or maybe does it?...
I am quoting this example because it is so simple. I think you could find out in no time if the queen of England has a personal telephone number - or not (although it should be difficult to know what it is
) but with the Japanese imperials even that simple information seems to be doubtful and impossible to find out.
True, at one time, Masako and Naruhito went with their daughter to a public park for her „koen-debut“ (see
http://www.theroyalforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=757984&postcount=92 and
http://www.theroyalforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=745781&postcount=66).
And it seems to be clear that they did this against the will of the IHA officials – so it is obviously not absolutely impossible for them to leave the palace on their own. But on the other hand, that was only a short time before Masako fell ill. It is possible that the IHA officials were taking their revenge on her for taking this liberty, and that it was that what finished her off. But again: just a guess.
Journalists like Ben Hills have been trying to find out what happens „behind the scenes“, and they may well be right. But in the end it all depends on whom you believe. Concerning the Japanese imperial family we have to rely much more on belief than on knowledge. (So what we are sharing here in the Japanese forum is rather a sort of religion than a science...
)
Concerning Masako being blamed as lazy, I have an opinion of my own. We know from the psychological sciences that when people are not allowed to live and show a vital side of themselves, they tend to repress this so-called „shadow“ and to project it onto another person or group of persons. In Japan laziness is deemed to be one of the greatest sins – and „laziness“ means, for example, to take all of the two weeks off that your work contract is giving you a right to...
Accordingly, Japan is - as far as I know – the only nation in the world where people die, literally, from overwork. So there must be a gigantic „shadow“ in the national psyche, as nobody is allowed to honestly confess that they would prefer to take a break and save their lives... This shadow is IMO being projected onto Masako because her illness is making her vulnerable for it. Besides that, I really do not think that this description has much to do with the real personality of Masako. If you look at her biography you see that she has always been fond of work and activity, and not so much of parties. She could have taken life much, much easier before her marriage but she did not choose to do so because she LOVED her work.
I personally do not think it a bad thing if a person prefers to work rather six hours than ten and goes out in the evening four times a week. (I am not Japanese, after all...
) We cannot be all equal. I would not think worse of Masako if she were such a person. But I really cannot believe that she is like that because I have never seen or heard a character so totally change in ten years as hers would be obliged to have done, would she really try to shy away from her duties and have become a party g.irl. I actually think that the party-Masako is formed by the eye of those watching her, by the transference of a Japanese nightmare.