Christian Bale was boring, Geoffrey deserved it a lot more.
My problem is that I am always affected by the actor's personaility, so that, if s/he is a jerk, s/he doesn't seem as talented as all that!
Ever since Bale's meltdown last year, I haven't liked him.
(I used to, but not now. I feel the same way about Russell Crowe, his antics ruin the acting for me).
So I too was disappointed that Geoffrey Rush didn't win, instead of Bale.