Humera
Moderator Emeritus
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2003
- Messages
- 7,805
- Country
- Canada
elizahawthorne said:I keep wondering...and I'm sorry if this is a completely ignorant question, it is not meant to be hurtful, I'm just curious as this is very new to me how one supports the claim that one is a descendent of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)?--this is a general question, I;m not wondering speciffically about the malaysian royal family, tho, my question is also very much related to them...also are all descendants of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) royalty? Or are there nonroyal descendants too?
-Eliza
I've asked the same question many times. Certainly most Muslim royalty makes the same claim. But so do many non-royals. They all have family trees to prove their descent. It is certainly a matter of great honour for people who make such claims. But in the process I find that the name of the Prophet (pbuh) gets exploited, certainly in the case of the average person out there who goes around saying they're descended from the Prophet. I can tell you that it is a common claim among non-royal Muslims, no matter where they live.
I think in the end, there's no point in dwelling on such things.
If the Malaysian, or any other Muslim royals, say they're descended from the Prophet, then I think one should just take their word for it. Because there's no absolute way of proving it wrong or right. Family trees can be faked or contaminated. But who is to know for sure.
The Jordanian Hashemite dynasty, for example, has a strong historical claim which is quite legitimate. I remember reading about it in my Islamic history class.