Rose Ball, Monaco: 2005 - 2024

[moby]

The worst has happened! Caroline is being featured on Go Fug Yourself.

 

[iloveroyals]

The worst has happened! Caroline is being featured on Go Fug Yourself.

Hilarious , and well-deserved !

OK, let me get this straight : this was actually a costume ball, but only Caroline and Charlotte knew it, so they were the only ones "appropriately" dressed, leaving Charlene, as usual, in the cold, and "inappropriately" dressed. That's a stretch !

 

[hibou]

No it's not a stretch. Please refer to my early post above. The Rose Ball is traditionally a COSTUME BALL. This year's theme was Movida a time period in the 1980's Spain and cultural events taking place at that time. Most don't like Caroline's dress and had it not become see-through in certain light, it actually was indicative of the quirky style of the theme of the ball. Not everyone was in costume. Those who understood the spirit of the event came in costume. Please note the Mardi Gras atmosphere of the event. The photographers naturally shot only the main "characters" but if you notice the surroundings you will see that Caroline was in "character" for the theme. Charlene and a few others were not. You need to look at the whole event.

 

[hibou]

I believe she would be EMPLOYED BY THEM! I don't believe they are worried about snubbing her, she would no longer be there if they didn't wish it! I'm sure they have a lot of respect for her since they grew up with her and she still stands by their side. However I imagine Albert and Caroline have no need for simple protocol instruction that others may still be in need of.

Correct Sandsla. She was in fact Princess Grace's Lady in Waiting and has remained with the family after Grace's death.

 

[iloveroyals]

No it's not a stretch. Please refer to my early post above. The Rose Ball is traditionally a COSTUME BALL. This year's theme was Movida a time period in the 1980's Spain and cultural events taking place at that time. Most don't like Caroline's dress and had it not become see-through in certain light, it actually was indicative of the quirky style of the theme of the ball. Not everyone was in costume. Those who understood the spirit of the event came in costume. Please note the Mardi Gras atmosphere of the event. The photographers naturally shot only the main "characters" but if you notice the surroundings you will see that Caroline was in "character" for the theme. Charlene and a few others were not. You need to look at the whole event.

Well, whatever the case may be, when in charge of an event of such magnitude, one should try to impose a certain coherence, and coherence was certainly lacking. (As opposed to when Grace was in charge: there, it was certainly clear when there were costume balls.) Charlotte's dress has been compared to enough styles, a Spanish eighties one not being one of them, unless I missed some posts. Who among her friends, also came in costume ? Or is costume all in the eyes of the beholder ?
As far as the photographers' lights go and everything, Caroline has been to enough events to be aware of such mishappenings. This is not Princess Diana as a nursery school teacher with the back lighting highligthing her legs.
I am sure I am not the only one that happened to have such a myopic view of the event that it needed to be explained to make us "get it".

 

[sm1939]

I think caroline should stay away from Karl Lagerfield's for the time being .

 

[La Bouche d'Or]

I'm wondering what Caroline's thinking now, when these unflattering pictures are all around the globe.

 

[Elly C]

Just looking at the 1st & last videos posted earlier & it seems Caroline was conscious of perhaps revealing too much up top when you look at her hand gestures. I dread to think how she might have looked when she first emerged from sitting in the limo on the way to the ball

 

[Moonmaiden23]

The worst has happened! Caroline is being featured on Go Fug Yourself.

That's funny! I guess even a style icon like the Princess is allowed an occasional misstep. She doesn't do it very often. She is still my ideal!

 

[Moonmaiden23]

Well, whatever the case may be, when in charge of an event of such magnitude, one should try to impose a certain coherence, and coherence was certainly lacking. (As opposed to when Grace was in charge: there, it was certainly clear when there were costume balls.) Charlotte's dress has been compared to enough styles, a Spanish eighties one not being one of them, unless I missed some posts. Who among her friends, also came in costume ? Or is costume all in the eyes of the beholder ?
As far as the photographers' lights go and everything, Caroline has been to enough events to be aware of such mishappenings. This is not Princess Diana as a nursery school teacher with the back lighting highligthing her legs.
I am sure I am not the only one that happened to have such a myopic view of the event that it needed to be explained to make us "get it".

I agree with you 100%. Even if this was a costume ball, Caroline surely could have gotten more into the "spirit of things" without flashing certain body parts best left covered up after age 35. She is one of the world's most tasteful, elegant women and I am her biggest fan but she belly flopped big time this year and there is no use trying to excuse it away. I totally "get it!"

As for Charlene, maybe she felt she couldn't pull off the "camp" look for the evening so decided to play it safe? She would have been torn apart worse than Caroline if she showed up in an outfit like the Princess's!

 

[Nad25]

Why on earth did Princess Caroline wear that dress?!!! what so nice about it??!!!

 

[loghan]

I think charlotte looked great.

 

[hibou]

I agree with you 100%. Even if this was a costume ball, Caroline surely could have gotten more into the "spirit of things" without flashing certain body parts best left covered up after age 35. She is one of the world's most tasteful, elegant women and I am her biggest fan but she belly flopped big time this year and there is no use trying to excuse it away. I totally "get it!"

As for Charlene, maybe she felt she couldn't pull off the "camp" look for the evening so decided to play it safe? She would have been torn apart worse than Caroline if she showed up in an outfit like the Princess's!

I have to agree about the body parts but I really wonder if she realized that under certain light it would become see-through? I also think you are right about Charlene but she does have a habit of getting things wrong most of the time. I do like her haircut and she finally got someone to professionally color her hair.

 

[rosana]

Why does Charlene have to color hae hair, isn´t she blond enough, i don´t think she has grey hair yet.

 

[giov]

I have to agree about the body parts but I really wonder if she realized that under certain light it would become see-through? .

Maybe Caroline didn't realize that, but nonetheless, as the top of the dress wasn't thight and didn't fit her well, I wonder why she didn't wear a bra, as any lady of her age should.
Is she a teenager?
I am afraid this is another sympton of mid-age crisis, as other posters said.

 

[Moonmaiden23]

I have to agree about the body parts but I really wonder if she realized that under certain light it would become see-through? I also think you are right about Charlene but she does have a habit of getting things wrong most of the time. I do like her haircut and she finally got someone to professionally color her hair.

hibou that's actually a great point. The Ball traditionally takes place in the evening as a soiree under very dim light. Perhaps the Princess didn't take the lighting into account when she tried on the dress? I have seen this gown on the runway and it's really not a bad dress. It's just not a "Caroline" look IMO.

At first I didn't like Charlene's haircut but now I do. Thank God she got rid of that stringy flyaway look she had! It only ever looked elegant when pinned into a chignon but let's face it...a young woman cannot wear a chignon 24-7.

Why does Charlene have to color hae hair, isn´t she blond enough, i don´t think she has grey hair yet.

No I don't think hibou meant grey hair. I think Charlene's hair had become damaged by years of exposure to chlorine and other elements while swimming so she has wisely had a colorist to highlight it.

Charlene's dress was beautiful she was radient. Someone asked about the mark on her arm I believe it is from a vaccination I have one also. We were given one in high school and whatever type it is everyone gets a mark on their arm. However Charlene's looks to have been infected at a time to leave that large a mark when some are only left with a slight discolouring of the skin.

Pierre is so handsome but I had to ask: I was looking at the HOLA! pictures and it looked to me like he was wearing slippers

The only thing that would have made Charlene look even better would have been some nice diamond/aquamarine earings as accessories. She is not wearing ANY accessories and the right earrings would have been drop dead gorgeous.

Someone mentioned Pierre's buzzcut. It's because he is currently serving in the military. I wish Andrea had been there, it's always nice when he shows up.

 

[tan_berry]

I think the event was very well organized and an absolute success. It seems the show the spanish people took there was fabulous. The decoration of the salon was excellent for the theme. Charlotte was exquisite. The little coat resembles a spanish "bolero", like the one that use the "matador". Charlene´s dress was pretty but absolute out of theme. The only exaggeration of the night was in the Caroline´s dress, but it was, at least, in the spirit of the ball.

 

[monaco70s]

The Rose Ball when Grace was alive was strictly dedicated to a country or a rose, and it was usually a ball to celebrate those elements. It wasn't a costume ball in her time...the pics where you see Princess Grace wearing costume dresses are from other events such as: the 100 years of Monte Carlo, a head dress gala in the Casino, and others, but never at a Rose Ball.

Princess Caroline in 1994 decided to renovate the ball and since then it's been destined to honor a theme and create a whole concept that deals with this theme, being reflected in the decor, the performers and such. In modern days it is not a costume ball, since guests are requiered to wear a tuxedo and a night dress, not a costume. Princess Caroline has never gone dressed fully in costume, yet she tries to wear maybe some elements that can be associated to the theme in her accesories...never seen her wearing a bowl of fruit on her head, a tango dress etc.

The themes have been:
1994: The Insolit, to honor the russian rose gardens
1995: Tango
1996: Caribbean
1997: 700th Anniversary of the Grimaldi family
1998: SBM, Monaco in the 50s
1999: Prince Rainier's Jubilee
2000: 2000, tribute to Fernando Botero
2001: The Desert
2002: Pop
2003: Africa
2004: China
2005: Brazil
2006: Reggae
2007: Gypsy

 

[hibou]

Maybe Caroline didn't realize that, but nonetheless, as the top of the dress wasn't thight and didn't fit her well, I wonder why she didn't wear a bra, as any lady of her age should.
Is she a teenager?
I am afraid this is another sympton of mid-age crisis, as other posters said.

I agree there comes a time when a women of a certain age needs to dress more appropriately but I also wonder if one has grown up as Caroline has, and been pictured so many times on magazine covers etc that it doesn't become more difficult to still look fashionable without becoming a fashion victim. Charlotte's dress was beautiful but too old for her. Maybe they should have switched outfits?

No I don't think hibou meant grey hair. I think Charlene's hair had become damaged by years of exposure to chlorine and other elements while swimming so she has wisely had a colorist to highlight it.

that's what I meant. blonde hair turns all sorts of colors with sun and chlorine damage not to mention all the mouse and hairspray it's subjected to these days, so it was best to cut it short and get the color normal.

 

[LadyMacAlpine]

that's what I meant. blonde hair turns all sorts of colors with sun and chlorine damage not to mention all the mouse and hairspray it's subjected to these days, so it was best to cut it short and get the color normal.

The damage should be gone by now and her color isn't normal she is a dark blonde light brown.

 

[RubyPrincess168]

I'm wondering what Caroline's thinking now, when these unflattering pictures are all around the globe.

Do you think royalty-by-birth have regrets about fashions they wear? I don't mean decades later what-was-I-thinking kinds of regrets - we all have those!

 

[MARG]

Maybe they should have switched outfits?

Maybe they did!

 

[Lakshmi]

I watched 2006 and 2007 Rose Balls. Themes were great, most outfits OK. I was very suspicious when I read about this year's theme first time. I just did not like it. And unfortunatelly many women, not only Caro got it wrong, choosing really bad outfits.

 

[cdm]

I didn't like Caroline's and Charlotte's outfits either. Mostly because they didn't fit well. They looked quite allright on the catwalk pictures. They shouldn't have made Caroline's dress longer.
I do like Chanel on Caroline, but most of the time I like the Chanel daytime outfits better than the evening gowns. My favourite Caro evening gowns were not Chanel's.
I did like the Movida theme though. I'm a big Almodovar fan. The decoration of the Sporting Club looked great.
Charlene's dress was beautifull, maybe she should have chosen an accessoire in the Movida fashion, but she was the best looking one of this ball.

 

[Duke of Marmalade]

First time that I think Charlene looked REALLY beautiful. The dress is ok but is being made look fantastic next to these hideous "dresses" of Charlotte & most of all Caroline. Were no mirrors around when they got dressed? Albert should at least have told his older sister to change her outfit before they went in front of the cameras. I always thought that Caroline was a bastion of class in dressing but this outing made not only look her cheap and highly unappropriate but also added up to Monaco's cheap & second class image. Lagerfeld must watch out that he doesn't end up as a caricature of himself.

 

[iloveroyals]

The Rose Ball when Grace was alive was strictly dedicated to a country or a rose, and it was usually a ball to celebrate those elements. It wasn't a costume ball in her time...the pics where you see Princess Grace wearing costume dresses are from other events such as: the 100 years of Monte Carlo, a head dress gala in the Casino, and others, but never at a Rose Ball.

Princess Caroline in 1994 decided to renovate the ball and since then it's been destined to honor a theme and create a whole concept that deals with this theme, being reflected in the decor, the performers and such. In modern days it is not a costume ball, since guests are requiered to wear a tuxedo and a night dress, not a costume. Princess Caroline has never gone dressed fully in costume, yet she tries to wear maybe some elements that can be associated to the theme in her accesories...never seen her wearing a bowl of fruit on her head, a tango dress etc.

The themes have been:
1994: The Insolit, to honor the russian rose gardens
1995: Tango
1996: Caribbean
1997: 700th Anniversary of the Grimaldi family
1998: SBM, Monaco in the 50s
1999: Prince Rainier's Jubilee
2000: 2000, tribute to Fernando Botero
2001: The Desert
2002: Pop
2003: Africa
2004: China
2005: Brazil
2006: Reggae
2007: Gypsy

Thank you for setting the record straight, monaco70s, and for doing the research about the past Rose Balls. I must say I was a little confused about this business about costume balls and the Rose ball being a costume ball, especially after rereading the official press release statement where nothing about a Mardi Gras ball was indicated and the dress code for ladies was just plain "evening gowns". It is then more accurate to say the Rose Ball has a theme and the guests can dress in the mood of the theme.

I also didn't know it had been renovated by P. Caroline in 1994 (great initiative on her part). The general setting, decor, etc, have always been beautiful, she is surrounded by a great team.

It would be nice if she could also resurrect the true costume ball. I remember the Swedish royal family doing a Renaissance fair style event, where they all got dressed up in period costumes and the two princesses (but also Queen Silvia and the gentlemen) looked gorgeous. I'd love to see Charlotte in a period costume. What would you suggest ? The medieval style does suit her face. I think an Arabian Night theme would make all the young ladies stand out and have fun. (And there'll be a rule for no lady over 35 showing a bare belly no matter how many belly dancing lessons they take before the event...). I suggest Elie Saab as their designer, he does such a wonderful job for Queen Rania. But there are others as well. Or how about a Japanese theme, and choose the costume designer who did the wardrobe for the 2 films that won awards recently? Unfortunately, I forget his name, but he is famous for his delicate use of color and fabric. Someone might help me out here.

I still think that if if you are going to have a theme, go to the source for the costumes or clothes. These are the people who have been trained with the tradition of the country and culture and they will want to rise to the occasion : what better publicity than a successful Monaco Rose Ball ?

 

[Tosca]

Olycom has also a picture gallery of the Ball:
Olycom - News

I agree with you Johnnie: Lagerfeld has always been a caricature. And also agree with your friend's statement about Caroline: she's appeared as if she thinks she's anointed by God, especially since she married EA.
I have the feeling that the only man who were capable of taking her "back to the earth", so to speak, was Stefano.

Hibou, I also wonder how could Caroline wear such dress without realizing it may have turned into a see-through one in that kind of light. She wasn't born yesterday; she's been in the spotlight since her birth, and she isn't a naive teenager anymore, although I doubt she might have ever been naive.
I think she could be an excellent photographer and a skilled editor in chief herself.
She wanted to shock the audience and demonstrate that she can still bear comaprison with younger women like Charlene (and perhaps her daughter? God forbid!)

I'm glad that Stephanie stayed out from the Ball. She must have realized that one circus is enough. I also have always though that she is the most caring and intelligent of the trio. She's a person that desperately needs love, especially after her mother's death. She saw her mother die, but instead of being protected by her family she was accused for killing her Mom.
I was shocked when reading an interview Albert gave to CHI mag some months ago, when he said: "It's true that we left Stephanie all alone after that car accident, but she never asked us for help."
What? If my sister had had such an accident I wouldn't have waited for her to come to me and cry: "Hey, I need help!" It clearly showed she needed help. No wonder that she tried search for someone to cherish her outside her family circle.

 

[lucien]

PPE Agency

Courtesy PPE/Nieboer/S.B.M./Realis

 

[thekla]

Olycom has also a picture gallery of the Ball:
Olycom - News

I agree with you Johnnie: Lagerfeld has always been a caricature. And also agree with your friend's statement about Caroline: she's appeared as if she thinks she's anointed by God, especially since she married EA.
I have the feeling that the only man who were capable of taking her "back to the earth", so to speak, was Stefano.

Hibou, I also wonder how could Caroline wear such dress without realizing it may have turned into a see-through one in that kind of light. She wasn't born yesterday; she's been in the spotlight since her birth, and she isn't a naive teenager anymore, although I doubt she might have ever been naive.
I think she could be an excellent photographer and a skilled editor in chief herself.
She wanted to shock the audience and demonstrate that she can still bear comaprison with younger women like Charlene (and perhaps her daughter? God forbid!)

I'm glad that Stephanie stayed out from the Ball. She must have realized that one circus is enough. I also have always though that she is the most caring and intelligent of the trio. She's a person that desperately needs love, especially after her mother's death. She saw her mother die, but instead of being protected by her family she was accused for killing her Mom.
I was shocked when reading an interview Albert gave to CHI mag some months ago, when he said: "It's true that we left Stephanie all alone after that car accident, but she never asked us for help."
What? If my sister had had such an accident I wouldn't have waited for her to come to me and cry: "Hey, I need help!" It clearly showed she needed help. No wonder that she tried search for someone to cherish her outside her family circle.

Did you notice how Caroline was lifting her dress on pictures 8, 9 and 10 of the gallery - very strange - like she wasn't showing enough skin already.
Also on the videos of Youtube - to me her behaviour was very strange a little erratic. Reminds me of Ernst August when he used to show up at official events - well let's say 'enthusiastic' - but now he seems to be on some sort of downers. What's your opinion? Do you really think Stephanie stayed away by choice - it seems to me they have an agreement of taking turns to avoid public appearances together. Steph at Albi's birthday - Caro at the Rose Ball.

 

[sebastian]

As for the Stephanie -not -showing -up -at- the -Rose Ball - thing ... she hasn't attended for years. It would be nice if she would again but obviously there's no need. It's not that Caroline and her can't stand eachother and therefor have to take turns.

And on that note: Stephanie's children were not banned from their grandfathers funeral.

Stephanie is living happy life right now.

I always wonder how people dare to judge the state of happiness of another person.