Alexandria
Heir Apparent
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2003
- Messages
- 3,207
- Country
- Canada
Smilla said:1. Cartoons exaggerate. That is their function. They should make you think. So they should make you think whether there is a connection between the Muslim faith and terrorism. You can answer yes or no to that question.
2. If a muslim journalist pulished a picture of Jesus and altered the cross as a bomb I would respect his freedom of speech. Plain and simply. The vatican wouldn't stage demonstrations or threaten to kill those people either. Most Christians wouldn't turn to violence either.
3. Sure you have the right to express your opinions. If you turn to violence, however, that is unlawful and only reinforces the criticism of Islam.
I agree totally with what you've said Smilla, but particuarly that the level of violence in response to the cartoons is unjustified. However offensive or distasteful the cartoons were, there are much better ways of decrying them then by storming the Danish embassies in various countries or burning the Danish flag. Such violence doesn't beget a better understand of the Islamic faith or, for those who (falsely) hold such a belief that Islam and terrorism are linked, these actions only serve to prove such ignorant assumptions as being true.
While I never had one feeling one way or the other about whether or not Queen Margrethe sould make a public statement about this situation, I am starting to lean more towards the belief that she shouldn't. Firstly, I had never considered as someone has pointed out in this thread, that a public statement by a woman of power would only serve to heighten the tension over this situation, but also that to some level, an official comment about it by the Queen would only serve to prove the point that violence does beget a response. And what can the Queen do about the situation now? The cartoons have been printed -- Queen Margrethe can't be expected to turn back the clock and recall the decision. And I feel that had only the negative action been the printing of the cartoons, then the smoothing of the relations should be on the Danish side. But with the amount of violence inflicted upon Danish property, I think the onus of smoothing over relations should now be more on the other side.