What is it with the skinny-people bashing around here?! Just as some are naturally disposed to be plump others are naturally disposed to be thin.
You made an interesting point. They are people who are naturally skinny. Not everyone who is skinny is an anorexic or has health problems. But I am pretty sure Charlotte is not one of this persons. She has the same body type that Caroline has, and Caroline is not naturally skinny.
Charlotte looks much more natural and healthy with a few more kilos.
An example of a naturally thin person? Take Beatrice Borromeo. She is a model, she is thin, but she looks healthy. You can see that she is a natural thin girl and she is perfect and beautiful the way she is.
Another example of a healthy thin person? Alice Dellal. She can be skinny, but look at her thighs. She's got flesh!
Charlotte is not naturally that thin. She only looked like that for a period, when she was around 16, and she did have eating disorders and looked emaciated and sick.
When a woman is naturally skinny her weight doesn't fluctuate as much as Charlotte's weight does. Take Keira Knightly. She's always skinny, you don't see her one summer looking a little bit plump to the point of people speculating about her being pregnant, and the next summer you can count her ribs. She is always skinny because she is like that. Being skinny is natural for her.
On the other hand, Charlotte's weight fluctuates quite a lot, as usually happens with people who try to be bellow their natural weight. Mind you, I don't think that Charlotte has a tendency to be fat, but she has a tendency to be
normal.
To me, Charlotte looks as someone who tries to be exageratelly thin, like Eugenie, whose head looks as big as Charlotte's. (the head is a very good clue. Naturally thin people are proportionated, they don't look as if they had gigantic heads).
And all this "she is riding" excuse is just bollocks. I am a rider since I was 7, I've compited for many years and I know many profesional riders, and horse riders don't have that kind of body.
This is a naturally thin Charlotte:
http://charlottemaripomeline.web-log.nl/photos/uncategorized/2006_08aug_17de_novella_2000_3.jpg
This is unnatural:
http://charlottemaripomeline.web-log.nl/photos/uncategorized/2002_6_juni_blauw_bikini.jpg